One day, one of my supervisors came to my office and requested that one of his employees shall be reassigned due to poor performance in his office. When I called the attention of the employee for his poor performance as verbally reported to me by his supervisor, he reacted: “Is he kidding, Madam? He always gave me a “Very Satisfactory” performance rating every rating period.”
At the end of the rating period, the employee just simply copies his or her previous performance appraisal forms and submits them to the supervisor for confirmation and signature.
On the other hand, majority of the supervisors are not honest in rating their employees. The supervisor gives a “Very Satisfactory” rating to the employee even if he or she doesn’t deserve it, as the supervisor is sick of getting arguments from his people when they didn’t get the rating they thought they deserve.
An appraisal is supposed to be informative for you and your employee. It ought to inform him how he’s doing in relation to performance targets. It is supposed to identify his strengths and the areas where he needs improvement. Conducted correctly, it can help you get the performance you need. But if you rate employees higher than they are worthy of, they begin to think they’re okay and might not be urged to do better.
Here are the four effective ways to make performance appraisal easier for you and your employee:
1. Make sure to evaluate employees fairly. Don’t play favoritism in rating employees. Establish uniform performance standards as your guide.
2. Stick to facts and shun evaluations of performance based on casual observations. Gather data and keep written records of performance of employees as basis of evaluation.
3. Keep a better balance between praise and criticism during your performance evaluation meeting. Commend the employee for the areas where he excels in performance and point out the areas where he needs improvement.
4. Select one or two goals for the employee to work toward instead of trying to change everything overnight. For the areas where he needs improvement, set two goals for him to achieve for him to improve his performance.
I know you also have your own list in mind and I am glad if you could share it with us by leaving your comments below this post.